This idea is far less formed than usual and that’s saying something because few of my ideas or things I write about here are particularly well formed.
They are often more of a glimpse into something I’m currently considering, but have been pondering for a while.
This is a far more raw kind of thought. While in some way or another it has crossed my mind, it’s never been exactly this clear.
Can God hate?
I feel like I write the follow sentence every time, but I guess it’s just part of my charm (or lack of creativity, whatever works for you).
It’s seems like the obvious answer is yes, but I’m starting to worry that it creates some serious problems.
And this is the raw nature of this particular idea. I’m working and thinking about the implications and possible problems that a God how can hate creates, but these ideas are really new and not fully formed at all. So if you see an obvious issue here I’m interested. I’m just starting to roll this idea around in my mind so any new ways to approach it are helpful.
I’ll lay out how I got here and the starting point for the possible problem I see.
It started with justice. Specifically the notion that we may put our idea of justice onto God rather than look at God for what He means when He talks about justice. Quick recap, so much of God’s work is restorative it stands to reason that His justice would be similarly restorative rather than mimic our punitive process of exacting justice.
This idea stems from a God who describes Himself as love.
God is love.
And so God’s justice must be love. It must take the form of love and be a display of love. Everything God does is an expression of love because He is love. To do something that isn’t loving would be counter to His nature and His essence.
As a tree can’t be any less a tree, God by virtue of His nature will be love.
So how is the hate we often ascribe to God an expression of love?
How is hate a loving act?
How is hate not counter to the very nature of God?
Most we agree that we shouldn’t hate people. We should love them, but I’m wondering if the type of love we are showing is God’s love of a projection of our broken understanding of love.
I was reading a blog earlier today and the writer was talking about how we should react with love no matter the situation. The write then went on to describe all the people we should love.
“Gays, lesbians, transgender people, heterosexual adulterers, atheists, white-lie tellers, good-churchgoers-without-a-shred-of-grace–any and all people who have issue with the hard words of Scripture–these are not our enemies.”
I posted the following comment
“I know for myself. If the way I was defined, labeled and grouped was based on a list of things people hate, I would struggle to find any reaction not matter how well intended as a loving one.”
And so again I’m left wondering, how do we lovingly hate?
Are we called to only love parts of people? To parcel them into pieces, those worthy of our love and those that we get to hate.
Is that the radical love of Christ or ours?
It may be, but I’m far less sure that’s how it’s supposed to work than I was in the past.